The
new HRD minister Prakash Javadekar
is the “right person in
the right place.” He is the one who has the personality combined with
diligence and pragmatism, he will be successful in extricating the HRD
ministry from the controversies and deficiencies. however has to cope
with numerous challenges to cleanse Indian education. the recently
released national policy on education report 2016 (NPER) has
convincingly argued that Indian education system is in a state of
“disarray”. the most important issue is that of the degree trading
deemed universities. the Tandon committee found “undesirable management
architecture” in most of the deemed universities, a reference to their
being family, rather than professionally, managed. the committee also
indicted the 44 varsities for “thoughtless introduction” of new study
programmes beyond the mandate of the original terms of grant of deemed
university status. it also concluded that none of them were engaged in
any meaningful research activity. when the government realised that the
public mood was against indiscriminately granting deemed university
status (later university status) to all sorts of private teaching shops
owned by unscrupulous persons, mainly politicians. with the floodgates
having been opened by Arjun Singh and reports of the poor quality and
unemployability of Indian university graduates causing alarm in industry
and media, the government was forced to a freeze sanctioning new
deemed universities, and placed existing ones under the scanner of the
Tandon committee. it is reported that at the time of the freeze order,
225 proposals for deemed universities were under the consideration of
the commission, of which 37 were from Tamil Nadu, 30 from Uttar Pradesh,
24 from Maharashtra, and 17 from Karnataka. moreover, the HRD ministry
constituted its own committee under the chairmanship of prof.
p.n.Tandon, to investigate existing deemed universities. the Tandon
committee’s recommended for derecognition 44 deemed universities was
accepted by the HRD ministry. as usual the managements of these
institutions approached the judiciary. the case is pending.in this
context, one aspect has to be made clear. UGC action to grant deemed
university status is a clear case of encroachment of state autonomy.
moreover, UGC is ill-equipped to monitor and control the functioning of
the deemed universities. therefore, the granting of deemed university
status should be stopped forthwith. the existing deemed universities may
be brought under the ambit of monitoring by central/state government.
Times of India, HRD Mantri’s real job is not fire-fighting, it’s education, July 10, 2016,